Victims: PG&E still has rickety power line near Paradise


FILE – In this Oct. 31, 2019, file photo, smoke from the Maria Fire billows above Santa Paula, Calif. A federal judge has approved a settlement that moves Pacific Gas & Electric closer to getting out of bankruptcy. The company cleared its latest hurdle Tuesday, Feb. 4, 2020, when U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali signed off on a deal to refinance billions of dollars in debt to pay off PG&E bondholders who threatened to cause problems. (AP Photo/Noah Berger, File)

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Pacific Gas & Electric is still operating a rickety power line near the one that ignited a 2018 wildfire that wiped out the Northern California city of Paradise and killed 85 people, according to an expert inspection conducted as part of a legal claim.

In an inspection just two months ago, an expert hired by the wildfire victims’ attorneys found a power line with rusty equipment and some parts apparently held in place by electrical tape. The expert compared the power lines to a year earlier and found the safety concerns remained.

The potential hazards were spotted along a transmission line known as “Cresta-Rio Oso,” about 100 yards (300 feet) from another line, known as Caribou-Palermo. A rusting piece of equipment that failed in 2018 on the Caribou-Palermo line has been blamed for causing the fire that destroyed thousands of homes and other buildings, mostly in Paradise.

The potential safety hazards were spotted along a power lines located in a remote canyon running along the Feather River in Butte County, about 25 miles from Paradise. PG&E had temporarily turned off the Cresta-Rio Oso line for maintenance before the destructive fire caused by the Caribou-Palermo line, which has since been permanently deactivated.

The latest findings, made public Thursday by lawyers for victims who lost family members and homes, come as PG&E tries to persuade California Gov. Gavin Newsom that the company has turned over a new leaf as it tries to emerge from a bankruptcy case stemming from more than $50 billion in claimed wildfire losses. Newsom has threatened a government takeover bid of PG&E unless the company proves it can operate more safely.

A federal judge has also been pressing the utility to provide evidence that it has improved its safety practices and is thoroughly inspecting its transmission lines to reduce the risks of future fires.

U.S. District Judge William Alsup is overseeing PG&E as part of a five-year criminal probation imposed after the utility’s natural gas lines triggered a deadly explosion in 2010. A federal jury found the company guilty of five counts of safety violations and the one count of obstruction.

Alsup responded swiftly after being informed about the potential problems on the Cresta-Rio Oso line in a letter from the expert inspector. He issued an order Thursday telling PG&E to be prepared to discuss the evidence during a Feb. 19 hearing in San Francisco.

PG&E has repeatedly said it has learned from past mistakes, prompting the company to intensify the inspection of 18,000 miles (29,000 kilometers) of overhead power lines in a service territory in Northern California that provides electricity to 16 million people.

Even so, the nation’s largest utility has acknowledged that its electrical grid needs so many upgrades that it will probably have to deliberately turn off the power periodically during hot and windy conditions when power lines can topple and start wildfires for at least a few more years in parts of Northern California to minimize fire risks.

In court documents filed in December, PG&E told Alsup the company had inspected 50,000 transmission structures in high-risk areas since the 2018 fire, using people and drones to check the condition of the equipment.

“All of the highest-priority conditions identified as a result of those inspections have been repaired or made safe,” PG&E assured Alsup. The filing didn’t specify which power lines had been examined and repaired.

PG&E didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment Thursday.

Alsup has already expressed skepticism about PG&E ability to detect safety hazards, despite the utility’s reassurances. He was particularly troubled by the company’s admission that a cable that had been inspected in July subsequently had detached from a transmission tower and may have caused another fire in Sonoma Couny last October. “What good are inspections that don’t find problems?” Alsup asked in a series of requests he made of the company in a Tuesday court filing.

The victims lawyers hired an expert, who they declined to identify, when they were preparing for a trial scheduled this year to help determine PG&E’s liability for the Paradise fire. But the trial became unnecessary when PG&E and the victims’ lawyers agreed to a $13.5 billion settlement covering the Camp Fire and other catastrophic wildfires in 2017.

Still, the victims remained worried about future wildfire risks posed by the PG&E power lines near their communities. Their lawyers alerted PG&E about the potential hazards on the Cresta-Rio Oso line before Thursday’s announcement,according to the attorneys.

Former Chico, California, police chief and wildfire victim Kirk Trostle stressed that the committee isn’t placing blame on PG&E, but trying to avert further devastation in areas still trying to rebuild.

“We could not bear the thought of another Camp Fire,” he said.

Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.