Rutland woman sentenced to probation, time served in deadly shooting of her husband


A Rutland County woman has been sentenced to seven years probation and time served in the deadly shooting of her husband.

Peggy Lee Shores has spent nearly four years in jail awaiting trial. She faced a second degree murder charge in the December 2016 death of her husband, David Shores.

Court documents show Peggy Lee Shores told police he accidentally shot himself when he tripped on their basement stairs. On Wednesday, Shores agreed to a plea deal that would reduce the charge to manslaughter.

“Anyone that knew my mom knew she didn’t do what the state is accusing,” said Shores’ son. “My mom is only taking this deal because she has so many people in her life she wants to come home to.”

The defense team called five witnesses to the stand, many close family members of David Shores. The victim’s family has frequently appeared at her court dates to show support for Peggy Lee Shores.

The state declined to question any of those witnesses. States attorney Rosemary Kennedy says they lack evidence of a motive, making it risky to bring the case to trial. She said a manslaughter charge could’ve been a likely outcome.

“We do not believe there is any doubt Ms. Shores shot her husband,” Kennedy said. “But what the state has not been able to gleam is why Ms. Shores shot her husband.”

Just prior to the judge’s decision, Shores shared a few words, herself.

“I’d just like to thank my family for being there,” she said. “I hope that you truly listen to everything they say because they said it all for me.”

More Headlines

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


Trending Stories

Latest Coronavirus Headlines

More Coronavirus

SkyTracker Weather Blog

More SkyTracker Blog